208. Danny Welbeck, 2012

Click to enlarge, and debate the strip below the line. Keith Hackett's verdict 1) There is no question of taking play back to the original foul: you rightly played the advantage, a goal was not scored and so you should restart with a corner kick. Also, caution the defender if you deemed his challenge reckless, or send him off if you decided he used excessive force. Dave Brooker wins the shirt. 2) I can see the manager's point, but the Laws require a whistle to be used, so you have to reject his offers. My advice is that all referees should carry two whistles of varying tones to avoid this sort of problem. I faced this situation several times in my refereeing career, so I always carried two different makes of whistle – an Acme Thunderer, which had a deep throaty sound, and my favourite Italian Balilla, which was high pitched. Thanks to Johannah Carroll. 3) Show him a yellow card and ask him to leave the field of play to dispose of the cigarettes and the lighter – they are not part of his approved equipment. He can only come back on during a stoppage in the game after you have checked him over. Thanks to Bob Horne. Competition: win an official club shirt of your choice For a chance to win a club shirt of your choice from the range at Kitbag.com send us your questions for You are the Ref to [email protected] . The best scenario used in the new YATR strip each Sunday wins a shirt to the value of £50 from Kitbag . Terms & conditions apply. For more on the fifty year history of You Are The Ref, click here .